feature·By Ron· 7 min read

The Chart That Forgot Women: How Poppy, Amy Lee, and Courtney LaPlante Made Rock Radio History

Poppy, Amy Lee, Courtney LaPlante — End of You chart history

The numbers are stark. Billboard's Mainstream Rock Airplay chart has been running since 1981. In 45 years of weekly rankings, not once had three women — or women-led acts — combined to lead the same song at number one. That changed in February 2026.

Poppy, Amy Lee, and Courtney LaPlante hit the top of the February 21-dated Mainstream Rock Airplay chart with "End of You." The milestone is straightforward: it had never been done before. Not even close. Not even two women at once. The achievement required three to get there first.

The Track

"End of You" is a standalone single, not attached to an album cycle for any of the three acts at the time of its chart peak. That makes the achievement more striking. The song earned its way to number one through sustained radio airplay, logging 2.5 million audience impressions — up 15% week-over-week — on Rock & Alternative Airplay in the tracking week ending February 12. It also charted at number 11 on Hot Hard Rock Songs.

The three vocalists bring distinct lineages to the same track. Poppy has spent the last several years building an increasingly heavy profile, collecting three top 10s on Mainstream Rock Airplay since 2024. LaPlante fronts Spiritbox, the Victoria-based band whose uncompromising sound has made them one of the most closely watched acts in heavy music — "Perfect Soul" peaked at number 14 on the same chart in 2025. And Amy Lee is Amy Lee — the voice of Evanescence, a band that has operated at the intersection of hard rock and something harder to categorize for over 25 years.

Rock Radio's Long Resistance

Understanding how significant this moment is requires understanding how structural rock radio's resistance to women has been.

Mainstream Rock Airplay launched in 1981. It was built in the image of classic rock radio — a format that, from the beginning, centered male acts, male voices, and male-dominated bands as the default. Women who recorded rock music were formatted as pop crossovers, slotted into adult contemporary, or simply not added to rotation. The assumption embedded in the format was that rock's core audience — white men 18-49, the demographic that program directors optimized for — preferred male voices. Decades of research have challenged that assumption. The format's programming choices have been slower to change.

The milestones of women at number one on Mainstream Rock Airplay are sparse enough that they read as a list of exceptions rather than a trend. Alannah Myles' "Black Velvet" reached number one in 1990 — a benchmark that stood until Nita Strauss and David Draiman's "Dead Inside" in 2021. In the 31 years between those peaks, Evanescence charted as a band, Halestorm secured consistent spots, and individual female features appeared — but the top of the chart remained almost exclusively male.

What drives this? Program directors at rock radio stations have historically favored male-fronted acts. Labels have mirrored that preference in which acts receive single promotion and marketing support. The consultants who advise stations on playlist decisions have operated from the same demographic assumptions since the format was created. The result is a chart that has reflected the industry's preferences, not the actual composition of the rock audience — which is broader, younger, and more diverse than rock radio's output has ever acknowledged.

"End of You" is a data point in that gap finally narrowing.

Three Roads to the Same #1

The three women who got here did not take the same path.

Poppy spent the early part of her career as a deliberately ambiguous internet presence — a YouTube persona engineered for uncanny discomfort, identity deliberately obscured. Whether she was a person, a character, or a corporate creation was the point of the exercise. What followed that period was a genuine pivot toward heavy music. I Disagree (2020) merged pop production with metalcore structure, and the records since have pushed further toward authentic heavy credibility. Her three Mainstream Rock Airplay top 10s since 2024 are not charity placements or novelty. They reflect a coherent artistic evolution from whatever Poppy was at the start toward something that belongs in this conversation entirely on its own terms.

Courtney LaPlante built Spiritbox from the ground up. The Victoria, BC band has operated at the intersection of extreme metal and melodic hooks since formation, and the combination has proven commercially durable in ways that surprised everyone outside their growing fanbase. LaPlante's vocal range — capable of clean melodic passages and death metal extremity within the same song — has made her one of the most technically imposing vocalists in heavy music. "Perfect Soul" at number 14 on Mainstream Rock in 2025 was the first indication that radio would engage with the heavier end of what Spiritbox does. A co-lead number one in 2026 is a different order of magnitude — and a validation of the band's refusal to sand down their edges for commercial accessibility.

Amy Lee needs less introduction. Evanescence's 2003 debut Fallen is one of the best-selling rock albums of the 21st century, a record that introduced an entire generation to the idea that heavy music could be orchestral, emotionally direct, and dominated by a woman's voice. Lee has spent the 25 years since navigating the space between rock, classical, and what Evanescence has always done — which is make large-scale emotional music that resists easy categorization. "Afterlife" reached number one on Mainstream Rock Airplay for the band in 2025. "End of You" marks the first time her name sits at the top as a lead act outside that context, alongside two collaborators who arrived at the same territory by entirely different roads.

What Actually Changes

The honest answer is: not automatically.

One song at number one does not restructure rock radio's programming culture. The format's default toward male-fronted acts will not be corrected by a single data point. Program directors change playlists slowly. The industry infrastructure around rock radio — labels that prioritize certain acts for single promotion, consultants who advise stations — runs on inertia built over decades.

What "End of You" does is make the argument with hard numbers. Mainstream Rock Airplay is a metric that radio stations, labels, and industry trade publications treat as objective. Poppy, LaPlante, and Lee just sat at the top of it. For the A&R executives who decide which acts get single support, for the program directors who decide what gets added to rotation, the chart number is difficult to argue against.

The chart rarely hands out firsts. This one took 45 years to arrive. Whether it accelerates what follows depends on the decisions the industry makes after it — but the milestone is established, the record is set, and the three women who did it got there on their own terms, by their own roads, without softening what they do to get there.

Poppy followed "End of You" with her Empty Hands project, which debuted at number 7 on Top Hard Rock Albums in early February. Spiritbox remains one of the most anticipated active bands in heavy music. Evanescence continues to place on the chart in ways that confirm the band is operating on durability, not nostalgia.

The number is one. The history is 45 years. Both of those things are true at the same time.


For more on Spiritbox, Evanescence, and women in heavy music, follow Metal Mantra's Metal News and Features coverage.

Never miss a story

Get the Metal Mantra Rundown

The biggest stories in heavy music, delivered M/W/F. Free. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Share:

Poppy

Finding Shows...

Related Stories